EASY AS PIE ONLINE ORDERING

FOR PICK UP OR DELIVERY

Order Online Now

Easy as Pie Pickup & Delivery

You don’t have to wait in long lines to get a great pie. Place your order online and you can pick it up or get it delivered. Choose from our seasonal menu and we’ll have it ready when you arrive or we’ll bring it straight to your door.

Now With On-Demand Delivery

Fancy Pies is serious about quality. Our wholesome yet upscale pies are made with a homemade slant from scratch using fresh ingredients and baked to perfection so you can taste the difference.

We are on a mission to bring our inventive pies to every home in New York City.

Order Fancy Pies On Postmates

New Markets Coming Soon

Online Ordering is Always Available

Local and Homemade

We specialize in homemade pies, baked from scratch with locally-sourced fresh ingredients in our signature all butter crust. Nothing is more satisfying than a fresh pie, the distinguishing taste of our seasonal pies will linger in your tastebuds for memories to come.

Experience the Taste of Home

Nothing beats a delightful piece of southern pie on any given day and there’s no substitute for time spent together sharing it. At Fancy Pies, we are proud to offer a delectable range of pies made with fresh ingredients. Whether you are having a birthday party, holiday party or you just want to treat yourself to a nice dessert, we’ll surely meet your expectations with our seasonal and catering menus.

Request a Special Order

NEW MARKETS COMING SOON!

Online Ordering is Always Available