FEATURED FLAVORS

Aunt Ann's Tangy Citrus Meringue - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Aunt Ann's Three Citrus Chess

$7.00 - $30.00
Select Size
Bessie's Boozy Butterscotch - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Bessie's Boozy Butterscotch

$7.00 - $30.00
Select Size
Dave's Mixed Up Berry - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Dave's Mixed Up Berry

$7.00 - $30.00
Select Size
Mama's Dutch Apple - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Mama's Dutch Apple

$7.00 - $30.00
Select Size

SEASONAL MENUS AVAILABLE YEAR ROUND

Please allow 7-10 business days for fulfillment, this does not include delivery time.

Summer Pies

Summer Pies

Fall Pies

Fall Pies

Holiday Pies

Holiday Pies

Winter Pies

Winter Pies

Spring Pies

Spring Pies

Baked Goods

Baked Goods