Aunt Shirley's Sweet Pear - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC
Aunt Shirley's Sweet Pear - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Aunt Shirley's Sweet Pear

Exactly what it sounds like– simply sweet pears in

Fancy Pies’s signature double crust.

Miss Lady's Cherry
Miss Lady's Cherry

Miss Lady's Cherry

Tart cherries with dried tart cherries thrown in for texture

in Fancy Pies’ signature double crust

Nana's Alabama Apple - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC
Nana's Alabama Apple - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Nana's Alabama Apple

A traditional apple pie of mixed varieties and lightly sweetened and spiced in Fancy Pies’ signature double crust
Southern Bourbon Pecan - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC
Southern Bourbon Pecan - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Southern Bourbon Pecan

A decadent pecan pie with dense and smoky bourbon
Southern Bourbon Sweet Potato - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC
Southern Bourbon Sweet Potato - Fancy Pies, a Seasonal Pie Shop by The Pie Lady NYC

Southern Bourbon Sweet Potato

This traditional southern favorite takes a turn for the better with Fancy Pie’s secret spice blend and dense and smoky bourbon

Seasonal Pies

Please allow 7-10 business days for fulfillment, this does not include delivery times.

Aunt Sara's Just Peachy
Aunt Sara's Just Peachy

Aunt Sara's Just Peachy

Juicy peaches with a hint of peach brandy

in Fancy Pies’s signature double crust

Mel's Jazzy Blueberry
Mel's Jazzy Blueberry

Mel's Jazzy Blueberry

Ripe blueberries bursting with flavor topped with a zesty lemon crumble
Miss Lady's Cherry
Miss Lady's Cherry

Miss Lady's Cherry

Tart cherries with dried tart cherries thrown in for texture

in Fancy Pies’ signature double crust

Vic's Pina Colada Escape
Vic's Pina Colada Escape

Vic's Pina Colada Escape

Crushed pineapples covered with rich coconut custard topped with toasted Coconut